Artie's Hate Blog #2: Team Fortress 2

Background.


Team Fortress Classic was the first retail release of any Team Fortress game
The history of Team Fortress dates back long before the name "Xbox" ever existed. It was THE first class-based multiplayer game out in the industry, and was a hit amongst the online gaming crowd. The first edition of the game featured all the classes that people have become familiar with from the most recent release: Scount, Pyro, Demoman, Solider, Heavy, Medic, Spy, Engineer, and Sniper. The game's major challenge was forcing a team to cooperate and use key classes to outsmart and defeat the other team's tactics, sucessfully completing whatever objective was required. Capturing a flag, blowing up a base, etc.

This game however was really just a modification of the game "Quake" and was not a retail release. So while there were a few servers that were full of 12v12 player matches, that's really where the activity stopped. However Valve, and emerging developer of the PC crowd with the release of Half Life. Picked up the Team Fortress guys and put them to work to create a retail game that people could purchase in stores. The result was "Team Fortress Classic" released in 1999. The game enamored previous fans of the Quake mod, and gathered up some Counter Strike fans aswell, but Team Fortress Classic was released amidst the Sega Dreamcast and Sony Playstation 2 releases. The majority of the gaming crowd had their attention focused else where, however there still remained an avid fan base for the game.

Medic, Engineer, Sniper, Scount, Demoman, Solider, Heavy, Pyro, Spy
Because the game was so popular, it obviously needed to have a sequel released to keep fans coming back. However it went through many delays and redesigns, and eventually was left in the dark to be forgotten about for a number of years. Gamers realized that Team Fortress had died, and moved on to other franchises such as Battlefield or Halo to fill their online gaming needs, class based, or not.

However on July 13th 2006 Team Fortress 2 was shown off to the public again, but sporting an all new look. Instead of being compared to realistic shooters like Counter Strike, TF2 looked a lot more like a violent Pixar movie than anything else. Everyone eagerly awaited it's release, along side Half Life Episode 2, and the mind-bending game Portal. And without much surprise, it was loved by everyone. Reviewers entitled it the "best multiplayer game out there" because of it's advanced team-work-required gameplay, and gamers all joined together to combat each other in the playful world of Team Fortress 2...


...everyone, except for me.

My Craziness


As I explained, Team Fortress 2 relies a lot on teamwork, which is what I consider the major fault of the game. In the early days of Team Fortress, when it was a Quake mod, everyone play First
Pyro, Engineer, Sniper, Spy, Heavy, Demoman, Medic, Scout, Solider
Person Shooters, knew what they were doing. It's very hard to find an idiot who doesn't know how to play games, but somehow manged to install Quake, and load up an advanced mod like Team Fortress, back in 1996. Because of this, the team gameplay made a lot of sense and worked very well, and no one ever thought it could work otherwise. They continued with Team Fortress Classic, although some morons started to leak through the cracks, but not enough to ruin the game.

But now it's 2008 (2007 when the game was released) and Team Fortress is available for consoles, and for PCs, with bare minimum system requirements. Because of the lower entry admission for players, a lot more "filth" gets into the game now, which pretty much ruins the game. You'll find yourself in a game where a medic is ubering himself and trying to kill as many guys as possible, or an engineer making a turret to protect your spawn as opposed to capture points. And even the occasional camper, who sits at one inane location, expecting to get one awesome kill, but really, is just wasting a lot of time doing nothing.

Guess who wins?
So even if it's an 8v8 game, two idiots ruin the balance, and you get horridly slaughtered. It's not just because there's an unfair advantage, but the game relies so incredible hard on team work it's unbelievable anyone can have any fun.

Each game is like a massive Rock, Paper, Scissors game, but obviously with a lot of dice rolls. For instance, maybe you're a Scout who turns a corner and, SURPRISE! A Pyro is there, you're fucked. There's no getting around it. You almost certainly, can not win. The Pyro rules at short range, and even if you're a Demoman or Solider, your only chance is blowing both of yourselves up, instead of just getting smoked.

Another situation would be. Maybe you're running across a plain, and a sniper or heavy happens to catch your eye, you're almost immediately dead, not to mention the chance of other enemies being in the area, you're pretty much screwed because of field advantages. Because of this, you never really feel like you're "bad" at the game, just that you always have bad luck. If you're not rolling with four other guys all the time, there's almost no chance that you're going to win a single skirmish between any player. And since there are a lot of idiots online, or a lot of people without microphones, or communication ability. You're never all going to be going in the same place, and thinking the same thing. So in the end it's a mess of a battle going on, and whoever wins might as well be settled by flipping a coin in the air.

In addition to this, you can almost always get the highest score in the game by being a medic or engineer. Just walk around healing
"LOL I OWND U" "STFU CAMPER"
whoever you see, never go too close to battle, and voliva! You've got 175 points at the end of the match while everyone else has 90, how did that happen? The game isn't fair with what classes get how many number of points.

Note the Medic's score, and everyone elses. Seems fair huh?
On a personal note, the game lacks any "real weapons." There's only three machine guns in the game. The medics needle gun, the Sniper's machine gun, and of course, the Heavy's main weapon. Everything else is either a fire, an explosion, a turret, or a shotgun blast. Most of which kill you in 2-3 hits, or in the turret and fire's case, 2-3 seconds. It's a weird type of combat that a game has never had before, and I personally do not like it. It relies on hitting your opponent directly, or else it does absolutely no damage. This amount of pin point accuracy doesn't seem to work with online gaming, especially a game like TF2, which is already hectic as f*ck.

And I also don't like that every map is very very small, and cramps a lot a lot of players in it. But that's just me.


Conclusion


Team Fortress' origins was when the game was it's best. When you open the game up for everyone and their little brother to player, the important team-based gameplay falls apart very quickly. But even then it doesn't matter, because unless everyone on your team is an ex-marine commander, they won't have enough communication skill or tactically knowledge to know how to handle each and every situation. How is everyone supposed to coordinate "Alright Heavy go for this, Pyros do this, and medics stick to groups of three." No one can, and no one ever does. The closest you'll get is "Alright, uber the heavy, and... sh*t I don't know."  Because the game relies so much on an unorthodox gameplay mechanic, it doesn't work as well as it could when opened up to the gaming public.

_________________

Agree? Disagree? Comment! It's alright to have different opinions. Just try to see something from another person's point of view, and perhaps my words have some merit.
Start the Conversation
9 Comments
Posted by Artie

Background.


Team Fortress Classic was the first retail release of any Team Fortress game
The history of Team Fortress dates back long before the name "Xbox" ever existed. It was THE first class-based multiplayer game out in the industry, and was a hit amongst the online gaming crowd. The first edition of the game featured all the classes that people have become familiar with from the most recent release: Scount, Pyro, Demoman, Solider, Heavy, Medic, Spy, Engineer, and Sniper. The game's major challenge was forcing a team to cooperate and use key classes to outsmart and defeat the other team's tactics, sucessfully completing whatever objective was required. Capturing a flag, blowing up a base, etc.

This game however was really just a modification of the game "Quake" and was not a retail release. So while there were a few servers that were full of 12v12 player matches, that's really where the activity stopped. However Valve, and emerging developer of the PC crowd with the release of Half Life. Picked up the Team Fortress guys and put them to work to create a retail game that people could purchase in stores. The result was "Team Fortress Classic" released in 1999. The game enamored previous fans of the Quake mod, and gathered up some Counter Strike fans aswell, but Team Fortress Classic was released amidst the Sega Dreamcast and Sony Playstation 2 releases. The majority of the gaming crowd had their attention focused else where, however there still remained an avid fan base for the game.

Medic, Engineer, Sniper, Scount, Demoman, Solider, Heavy, Pyro, Spy
Because the game was so popular, it obviously needed to have a sequel released to keep fans coming back. However it went through many delays and redesigns, and eventually was left in the dark to be forgotten about for a number of years. Gamers realized that Team Fortress had died, and moved on to other franchises such as Battlefield or Halo to fill their online gaming needs, class based, or not.

However on July 13th 2006 Team Fortress 2 was shown off to the public again, but sporting an all new look. Instead of being compared to realistic shooters like Counter Strike, TF2 looked a lot more like a violent Pixar movie than anything else. Everyone eagerly awaited it's release, along side Half Life Episode 2, and the mind-bending game Portal. And without much surprise, it was loved by everyone. Reviewers entitled it the "best multiplayer game out there" because of it's advanced team-work-required gameplay, and gamers all joined together to combat each other in the playful world of Team Fortress 2...


...everyone, except for me.

My Craziness


As I explained, Team Fortress 2 relies a lot on teamwork, which is what I consider the major fault of the game. In the early days of Team Fortress, when it was a Quake mod, everyone play First
Pyro, Engineer, Sniper, Spy, Heavy, Demoman, Medic, Scout, Solider
Person Shooters, knew what they were doing. It's very hard to find an idiot who doesn't know how to play games, but somehow manged to install Quake, and load up an advanced mod like Team Fortress, back in 1996. Because of this, the team gameplay made a lot of sense and worked very well, and no one ever thought it could work otherwise. They continued with Team Fortress Classic, although some morons started to leak through the cracks, but not enough to ruin the game.

But now it's 2008 (2007 when the game was released) and Team Fortress is available for consoles, and for PCs, with bare minimum system requirements. Because of the lower entry admission for players, a lot more "filth" gets into the game now, which pretty much ruins the game. You'll find yourself in a game where a medic is ubering himself and trying to kill as many guys as possible, or an engineer making a turret to protect your spawn as opposed to capture points. And even the occasional camper, who sits at one inane location, expecting to get one awesome kill, but really, is just wasting a lot of time doing nothing.

Guess who wins?
So even if it's an 8v8 game, two idiots ruin the balance, and you get horridly slaughtered. It's not just because there's an unfair advantage, but the game relies so incredible hard on team work it's unbelievable anyone can have any fun.

Each game is like a massive Rock, Paper, Scissors game, but obviously with a lot of dice rolls. For instance, maybe you're a Scout who turns a corner and, SURPRISE! A Pyro is there, you're fucked. There's no getting around it. You almost certainly, can not win. The Pyro rules at short range, and even if you're a Demoman or Solider, your only chance is blowing both of yourselves up, instead of just getting smoked.

Another situation would be. Maybe you're running across a plain, and a sniper or heavy happens to catch your eye, you're almost immediately dead, not to mention the chance of other enemies being in the area, you're pretty much screwed because of field advantages. Because of this, you never really feel like you're "bad" at the game, just that you always have bad luck. If you're not rolling with four other guys all the time, there's almost no chance that you're going to win a single skirmish between any player. And since there are a lot of idiots online, or a lot of people without microphones, or communication ability. You're never all going to be going in the same place, and thinking the same thing. So in the end it's a mess of a battle going on, and whoever wins might as well be settled by flipping a coin in the air.

In addition to this, you can almost always get the highest score in the game by being a medic or engineer. Just walk around healing
"LOL I OWND U" "STFU CAMPER"
whoever you see, never go too close to battle, and voliva! You've got 175 points at the end of the match while everyone else has 90, how did that happen? The game isn't fair with what classes get how many number of points.

Note the Medic's score, and everyone elses. Seems fair huh?
On a personal note, the game lacks any "real weapons." There's only three machine guns in the game. The medics needle gun, the Sniper's machine gun, and of course, the Heavy's main weapon. Everything else is either a fire, an explosion, a turret, or a shotgun blast. Most of which kill you in 2-3 hits, or in the turret and fire's case, 2-3 seconds. It's a weird type of combat that a game has never had before, and I personally do not like it. It relies on hitting your opponent directly, or else it does absolutely no damage. This amount of pin point accuracy doesn't seem to work with online gaming, especially a game like TF2, which is already hectic as f*ck.

And I also don't like that every map is very very small, and cramps a lot a lot of players in it. But that's just me.


Conclusion


Team Fortress' origins was when the game was it's best. When you open the game up for everyone and their little brother to player, the important team-based gameplay falls apart very quickly. But even then it doesn't matter, because unless everyone on your team is an ex-marine commander, they won't have enough communication skill or tactically knowledge to know how to handle each and every situation. How is everyone supposed to coordinate "Alright Heavy go for this, Pyros do this, and medics stick to groups of three." No one can, and no one ever does. The closest you'll get is "Alright, uber the heavy, and... sh*t I don't know."  Because the game relies so much on an unorthodox gameplay mechanic, it doesn't work as well as it could when opened up to the gaming public.

_________________

Agree? Disagree? Comment! It's alright to have different opinions. Just try to see something from another person's point of view, and perhaps my words have some merit.
Posted by JamesF

i <3 Team Fortress 2. I enjoy the cartoon art style very much.

You're sort of griping about class based games in general. Yes the Pyro will win if you turn a corner and he's right there. That's how it works. But if a pyros far away from you and you're, say, a sniper, or a heavy, that pyro is done for. You get screwed, but you also get to screw people over too. That's how class based games work.

Posted by Louis

Nice read.
I could never get into Team Fortress 2. Like you said, the game is structured around team strategies to defeat the opposition. Without it, you're screwed. It seemed as if every game I played was based upon pot luck. I had no idea what was going on because there was no communication and a lack of organisation. Everyone picked their class and rushed to rack up the kills. It destroyed the sole purpose of Team Fortress.

Posted by Quadrifoglio

I hate TF2. It required you to be too much of a team-player for my tastes. I want to be able to go Rambo on everyone's asses, and you can't really do that in TF2.

Posted by Dr_Feelgood38

I'm in a bit of a gray area when it comes to TF2. I really loved the game for like the first 3 weeks that I bought it. After a while the fun started to slowly die as I noticed the flaws one by one. At first I was just blinded by my fanboyism for Valve thinking that they would never release a bad game, but TF2 was just not that good. I remember scenarios where I would be injured and the medic would just ignore me and stay next to the heavy or places where there were turrets that couldn't be destroyed because they were placed in small areas that were hard to hit. By the time you fired off a shot you were dead. But whatever, I still like to go back to it like once a week or something.

Posted by Demilich

6/10

Not bad trolling. This is what gave it away though;

"you can almost always get the highest score in the game by being a medic or engineer"

Posted by Tru3_Blu3

I agree with JamesF. TF2 is meant to be a rock-paper-scissors game. While I do agree that the game focuses way too much on teamwork, the feeling of using teamwork is nothing but satisfactory.

The only thing that really pisses me off are the Demomens' mines. Cheapest thing out there.

Posted by iFresh

I still love the game, Artie i believe  what you have a problem with is how the game is balanced

Posted by Gigaman

You're lookin' at it wrong. The medic has obviously been a longer time in-game, hence the higher score.

Plus, that feeling like the game's unbalanced when you're alone is the whole purpose of team-based combat. You gotta stick with the group to do well.