I can't quite decide between Sacred 2 and Dark Messiah of Might and Magic: Elements. Sacred 2 just seemed to be so unforgivably broken in just about every way (plot, dialogue, pacing, assortment of powers, etc) that I went through it simply to see how far the trainwreck would progress. Me and my buddies probably got more enjoyment out of the sheer awfulness of the game than we did from the best games of the year.
 
DMoMaMasdlSIddfhw: E, on the other hand, is straight up awful in a way that brings no enjoyment. It's just flat out bad in every way possible.