Grim Fandango. The original was, at best, a 4 star game due to the horrible controls. The setting/characters/story/character design/etc... are all great, but with point and click controls, the game would be close enough to perfect.
Dying Light - I have this on my Steam wishlist, although, I should probably remove it. Maybe instead I should just replay Mirror's Edge, but with the gamma set to make it look brown and murky.
Life is Strange - I suppose theoretically I should be into it, but the stuff I've seen hasn't exactly piqued my interested. Maybe I've just had my fill of time travel/time manipulation games :|