I could be wrong, but looking at the screenshots, it looks a lot lower res then last time I played. If you turn up all the settings to max in that config tool and then the mess of options menus in game (like finding a 16:9 aspect ratio), it actually looks pretty nice even now IMO, particularly when compared to like EQ1, which FFXI was closely modelled after. Also I hope you used a controller, makes the archaic controls and menus more bearable. Not to mention that there's a lot of 3rd party addons most people use that skip the whole playonline login process now...
I totally get that the game is both horribly complicated and unapproachable these days, both by how much the original, 2002 version didn't give a fuck about you, and how all of the new tutorial quests are overwhelming. The original version was like "here's the town, get on out there!" and you kind of figured things out by trial and error, or by consulting a guide, or asking people. Annoying but just took time.
However, now there's endless quests and menus you're fighting the whole time that definitely makes the new player first 10 hours way more complicated. Streamlines the whole 1-99 process but complicated. Personally the times in recent years I went back I played on a private server for the 75 cap era experience.
It's definitely a relic of its time; you can excuse the archaic MMO design of the original launch due to being pre-WoW and also designed for PS2s. No updates to that are less excusable (well maybe; according to the devs the only way they can develop it further is on like the last working PS2 devkit lol).
I still enjoy the battle system, being slow-paced, using my macros for everything (never using the battle menu lol). Skill chains and magic bursts were great, with a party (still can get that on private servers at least). I always liked getting my newest, coolest weapon skill, the moment I unlocked stringing pummel for my puppetmaster was great.
Two things I think that FFXI still has above FFXIV are its community and incentives to do the end-game content. In FFXI you had to rely on other people, otherwise you'd hit a wall real quick. In FFXIV, it's an MMO but I don't need to talk to anyone hardly. Also in FFXI it feels like there's always some amazing piece of uber gear I need to go figure out some additional battle system to go get, my character is getting stronger over time with all these crazy gear pieces that you swap on the fly. Less true now in 2020, but not long ago (probably in fresh Adoulin era at the latest) you had at least a dozen worthwhile end-game systems to go fight to get stronger. FFXIV on the other hand... you grind tomestones and it hands you the best gear in the game (or almost best gear in the game). If you want to be optimal you can do the hardcore raids, but a tiiinnnyyy percentile of the community (at least on NA) actually participates these days. Whereas in FFXI, at level cap, the end-game gear grind is the game.
That said, I play FFXIV these days since I sadly don't have the time commitment required for FFXI anymore and FFXI is in maintenance mode (some story content came out in August, the first in 5 years which was pretty cool though).
Log in to comment