I have plenty of fun with games that review poorly. Probably the most recent being Deadpool, I don't know why but I have liked what I have played so far.
Another one that immediately comes to mind is the first Two Worlds. For whatever reason I ended up getting hooked on that game and put somewhere in the neighborhood of 40 hours into it.
I also put a pretty large amount of hours into Defiance, which I thought was a ton of fun, but it does not seem to be reviewed very well.