I don;t think enough of you are thinking about small games, downloadable games. I spent alot of time playing dungeon defenders, and I really like the game. over the past few months I spent 1/3 of my time playing dungeon defenders, 1/3 uncharted 3, and 1/3 skyrim. Now how do you rate the 3 of these games. Lets start with DD which is the smallest and simplest of the 3, if you just comparing them it would have to be a the bottom. It looks the worse, has the worse music, shortest story, it's lacks any twists. It is a tower defense game that lets you fight alone with your towers all in the unreal engine. this would have been a console game from 10 years ago. Like I said though, I liked it, it does what is says, nothing special.
Now look at skyrim, which I;m playing on my PS3. I love the game and got hooked in the massive world and story. BUT THE GAME IS FUCKING BROKEN, I stopped once and waited for the dragons to stop flying backward. Now I am waiting for the next patch cause I guess my save is to big and game crashes after 20 mins no matter what I do now. The question is how do you score it? it looks better, better story, more complex, and is open world, but I can't play it right now.
As for uncharted 3, let me start with uncharted 2. I play UC2 and was blown away it really is like you're playing a movie at times. after the second one I went back and played the first one, It was easy to see the differance in grafixs and game play. the story telling was still there but the game just wasn't as good. Now I thought UC3 was near perfect well rounded game, my biggest problem was not that the story was too linear but that it lacked replayablity. after going the whole game once, I sat there and looked at it wondering if I should raise the difficulty and try again, just didn't want to.
So lets score the 3 games, I really enjoyed uncharted 3 and would have to say it was more fun than skyrim, at the same time it looked better and ran smoother than skyrim. However I played though dungeon defenders and when I was done I wanted to go back and level my guy up, when I hit the level cap I wanted to start a new guy. Than I wanted to pump it up to insane a try it with my decked up guys, than go online a play with others to show off my dude.
In the end If I were to rank each one I would put dungeon defenders at 10, uncharted 3 at 9, and skyrim at 8. that all said if skyrim worked properly on my ps3 I would be playing it right now. In the end there is no easy or far way to compare anything.
Log in to comment