I take no side to this internet social war, and I don't think Giant Bomb, with its integrity and open agenda of "dumb video game fun", should be a battleground for this war either.
I'm happy that the GB staff have mostly minimized direct partisanship to either side of this movement other than ultimately acknowledging that online trolls are bad. I wouldn't label the GB staff SJWs, anti-GGers, or pseudo-journalist agenda-pushers from the statements made here. They don't like seeing some people they know getting hurt by nameless people on the internet, and that doesn't make them "corrupt journalists." I just hope the staff does't fall victim to (intentionally or not) being lumped into a group they don't represent.
Jeff's criticism of GG's message ambiguity here is on point, and applies to both vague "sides" in this war. There has been deception, false flagging, censorship, doxxing, and a lot of dumb, irresponsible comments and actions from both "sides," in addition to the broadly publicized death threats. Some activists on both sides enjoy the rah-rah atmosphere of fighting for their own ethics, while others speak out only to seek more public recognition and legitimacy among their peers.
As a GB community member, I think that the staff and community should (and pretty much does) avoid making large, sweeping "fuck those guys" comments to either side without reading deeper, past the superficial inflammatory headlines on blogger sites, subreddit links, and tweets. Attacking and generalizing without understanding the context only stifles any real conversation and fans the emotional fire.
Please don't make hasty assumptions, don't bandwagon, and don't get caught up in partisanship. Not all game journalists are in bed with the industry, not all gamers are bigots, not all feminists are ignorant. But, sometimes, not all Giant Bomb members aren't assholes. Skepticism, even - or especially - regarding one's own views is essential, despite what many internet communities seem to show.
GB staff, your silence was well heard by me, but I'm also happy that friends in the industry may feel fortified against undue internet hate because of your words.
I just hope the staff and the community of this site don't start trying to shout above the deafening hateful screams from both sides of this internet war.
I just want to hear what Vinny has to say about Duck Dynasty.
Log in to comment