Red Dead Redemption, I played it for the first time a month ago, I'm going to attribute it to not aging well, but I really didn't like it and the amount of praise it still gets completely baffles me.
Yes, another one! I did not get the RDR either. I love western films so this game should have been fantastic according everything I have heard. But it just felt bad - and even played it trough to see if it gets good and it doesn't. Undead nightmare was enjoyable, so I think my problem with RDR is that it takes itself way too seriously. (I think I have same problem with GTA4 - hated it. Ballad of Gay Tony was good.)