CherokeeJack

I don't really remember doing that, though I probably have at least once. Portal and the first Lego Star Wars are the closest I can think of, but I doubt that either of them really took only one sitting.

I was still going through the archived shows when I started playing Prince of Persia (08), so for most of the game I just muted the audio and listened to bombcasts instead.  
 
It was nice.

Yeah, the visual style looks kinda awful.

No thanks, I can get most of them on disk for 10 bucks.
Viva Pinata, for instance.

So what was the DS game on top of Luchadeer?

It's between that little skit they did in a 2008 (?) E3 podcast about local TV coverage of E3 ("This is not your parent's Pac-Man that you played in the arcades with a quarter!"), and the whole half-episode about GI Joe (especially Ryan trying desperately to get back on topic).

Oh, and pretty much every time they do the "YOU ARE THE _____ !!!" thing.

Loving these lists.