Some good points here. Sounds like it's been brought up before--I admit I was surprised there wasn't already a thread on this particular incident when I looked. To address a couple of the points I've seen multiple times:
Just skip it -- Yeah, that's obviously a solution but not a good one for me, since I listen during my driving commute and scrubbing through a 10+ minute conversation to figure out when they stop talking about a particular thing is not my idea of a good time, or safe.
I like listening to all their opinions - I do too! I thought I made that clear in the original post. I also would like--and welcome--everyone's opinions. It didn't bother me that both podcasts, for instance, talked about the Xbox One hardware revisions because Brad kind of just skimmed over the facts of the story (probably coincidentally but hopefully maybe because he knew Beastcast dove real deep into it) and we went directly into their personal takes. But, continuing to use the Coleco example, that was not ten minutes of opinion. That was Jeff explaining the entire back story to an obviously perplexed Brad and Drew.
They're separate podcasts, I don't listen to both, who cares? - As a fan of the bombcast for like what, 6, 7 years, I just want them to be the best they can be while respecting my time. As a comparison, the Idle Thumbs podcast try to make sure to A) not rehash stuff they've already covered, B) point to other podcasts on their network (or even other podcasts like giantbomb!) for insight on a particular topic and C) always pimp their other shows, with actual knowledge of what that show discussed. Everyone who says they only listen to one or the other only kind of further proves my point; if they did a better job of bringing up stuff from other podcasts, and strived to better make each one unique/worthwhile, maybe they could grow the listener base. Is that so bad?
Log in to comment