I tossed up my own Battlefield: Bad Company review (not sure if there is a way to direct link to individual user reviews).    It is one of those reviews where I disagree with the site review a fair amount, but at the same time I agree the game is still a good game.  I couldn't decide between 3 and 4 stars...  I chose 4.  I might change it to 3 later.  One thing that does worry me a bit is that Giant Bomb's reviews in general seem a lot less critical than ...  I like.  I know they focus on their opinion and all but the games they recommend seem to have little to no notes about problems.  There aren't that many games where flaws here or there aren't worth noting.