@believer258: There are Eroge stories that will make cry and also have tons of sex scenes in it. People dismiss these games because they have hardcore scenes in it without even take a look at it. Pf course you can say that you do not like it but saying it is crap just because it has porn in it?
It's not crap just because it has a lot of sex in it, it's crap because it appeals to nothing more than a person's most base desires. There's nothing wrong with that, but it hardly deserves any sort of award.
I believe the whole point of the thread is that it actually does appeal on other levels and is being ignored because of the sex stuff.
But OP, dawg, it is perfectly okay to ignore a game for one COMPLETELY fun-decimating fault. Especially to contend for something like GOTY.
Just because merit might exist in the product, you can't ask people, especially major publications, to slodge through something like that to find it.