My Probably GOTY 2013 List
Honorable mentions
Tomb Raider, but that game sets the player up for such thrill and excitement only to slink into mediocre combat and drawn out set-pieces.
Assassins Creed IV: I went back and played Assassins Creed III after playing Black Flag and it's very clear that this is a greatly improved game, but AC just isn't noteworthy enough to put on GOTY lists anymore.
Battlefield 4: It's a very nice looking game but not my kind of thing.
DmC: It knows what it is and does it well, I just didn't feel properly motivated to finish it...
Bioshock Infinite: I was profoundly moved by it's beautiful landscapes and the religious imagery at the start as well as scenes of Booker and Elizabeth moving through the lighthouses at the end but the combat just wasn't enjoyable enough.
GTA 5: It had some fun moments and I enjoyed the story but it just wouldn't run properly for me on my 360, the pop-in was atrocious, literally fences and cars rendering in 5 feet in front of my car, ruined the whole experience for me. And the complete shit-show of the online launch was just pathetic. I guess it was interesting to watch from an industry standpoint, but what a fuck up that was...