I guess I represent a minority here. I prefer a larger scale, personally. I especially enjoy the simple Pros/Cons at the top that Gamespot has (I noted Gamespot in a positive light for once. So fucking sue me.) GiantBomb isn't so bad with their little once sentence blurbs before the review either.
Honestly, there are so many games out there that are barely worth my time I'd rather not read a full review unless I'm given a reason to care. If I see something interesting in the "Pros" section I'll take a look at the review. That is, unless I'm already interested in the game.
Now I'm not saying that the 100 scale (or 10 scale with decimals) is always done properly. Actually it almost never is. Much like how many professors grade papers, a grade of 50 isn't generally "half perfection" as I'd like to see it. I would like to see one site do this properly some day. I'm also not saying that GiantBomb has a shitty rating system. It's been alright so far. I would just prefer a "true" 100% system.
Log in to comment