GameFly Issue Paragon +25


So I had rented BioShock 2 from GameFly.  About a week went by and I hadn't recieved it, usually it only takes two or three days tops for them to send me a game.  I reported it missing and they quickly sent me another copy of the game.  I also reported it to the USPS.  A couple days passed and I got the copy they sent.  A few more days passed and I got the original copy(or maybe the second copy, that isn't clear at this point maybe the USPS got my complaint and found it).   
 
Either way at that point I had two copies of BioShock 2 and only one was accounted for.  I could keep BioShock 2 for free and get away with it, or more likely sell the game.  I told several friends and even my Mom about it.  Everybody either assumed or suggested I'd be keeping it. 
 
Here is what I did.  I sent back the second copy the next day, kept the original.  They got the second copy thinking it was the only one thus taking it off my "GameQ".  Meanwhile I've been playing and beating BioShock 2 as they process my next game.  Today, I've decided I'm either going to beat it or give up on it.  I contacted GameFly told them I had "recently" recieved the second copy and that I'd be sending it back tomorrow, Monday(the next day the USPS was open). 
 
Paragon +25 
 
Does it make it any less of an honest deed if I come here and tell everybody about it?
Start the Conversation
1 Comments
Posted by HatKing

So I had rented BioShock 2 from GameFly.  About a week went by and I hadn't recieved it, usually it only takes two or three days tops for them to send me a game.  I reported it missing and they quickly sent me another copy of the game.  I also reported it to the USPS.  A couple days passed and I got the copy they sent.  A few more days passed and I got the original copy(or maybe the second copy, that isn't clear at this point maybe the USPS got my complaint and found it).   
 
Either way at that point I had two copies of BioShock 2 and only one was accounted for.  I could keep BioShock 2 for free and get away with it, or more likely sell the game.  I told several friends and even my Mom about it.  Everybody either assumed or suggested I'd be keeping it. 
 
Here is what I did.  I sent back the second copy the next day, kept the original.  They got the second copy thinking it was the only one thus taking it off my "GameQ".  Meanwhile I've been playing and beating BioShock 2 as they process my next game.  Today, I've decided I'm either going to beat it or give up on it.  I contacted GameFly told them I had "recently" recieved the second copy and that I'd be sending it back tomorrow, Monday(the next day the USPS was open). 
 
Paragon +25 
 
Does it make it any less of an honest deed if I come here and tell everybody about it?