@heycalvero: "I always find it a bummer that most people will associate Michael C. Hall with Dexter Morgan rather than with David Fisher." Me too, David is a far better character.
As for Dexter I felt like the show only needed one more season after 4 to feel complete but they dragged things out so much and it was bad and boring with little tension to speak of. Season 6 especially was a slog.
I remember liking Heavy Rain a whole deal at the time, because it at least was trying something most games are not. Looking back on it, the game is a hot mess. Some solid music at least. I agree with those above me that the games critical success boils down to it standing out as a game actually trying something and being noteworthy of that sort of discussion and thus being praised regardless of the actual quality of it.