GOTY 2014
There weren't a lot of games that grabbed me in 2014 - half of the games on my list didn't even come out this year! That being said, I've probably spent more time with my top two choices, than I have with any other game these last couple of years.
So while the breadth of games didn't really impress me this year - I did enjoy the heck out of the few games that did.
Note: I was tempted to put Dark Souls (the first one) on this list, having recently replayed it, but I decided that the souls-series was already sufficiently represented.