Something went wrong. Try again later

Irishdoom

This user has not updated recently.

400 0 31 14
Forum Posts Wiki Points Following Followers

That State of Story: Uncharted 2


No Caption Provided
I realize that in a lot of ways a good story is way down on the list of important gaming elements.  It is a largely visual medium that focuses primarily on interactivity, so it doesn’t necessarily supply the same blank tapestry fit for a compelling narrative like a novel or film.  The fact remains, however, that video games are no longer just “child’s play.”  As the age demographic of gamers skews ever upward, the demand increases for more meaningful experiences.  Strong storytelling is an excellent way to keep older gamers interested, and Uncharted 2 is an excellent example of how the industry is slowly moving from the old ways of game story as an afterthought to fully fleshed-out, engaging narratives. 
In the early days of video games, they were created by small, dedicated teams that had to put a whole package together: graphics, gameplay, sound and story.  These small teams put a premium on flexibility and multiple skill sets – dedicated writers didn’t really have a place.  It made sense in the early days of game development.  After all, how strong a story do you actually need for Super Mario Bros. or Tetris? 

As budgets and development teams have evolved, writers have begun to play a much more pivotal role, and the overall quality of the narrative in games has increased tremendously as a result.  Just take a look at some of the best games of the last six months or so, and you’ll see that good writing playing a pivotal role – Batman: Arkham Asylum, Assassin’s Creed II, Mass Effect 2, the list goes on and on. 

When I first played through Heavy Rain, I thought it would be the ideal example to hold up in order to address the state of storytelling, but I was wrong.  I got too hung up on some of the story’s foibles that were largely related to bad translation – then I played Uncharted 2.  (I’m late to the party, I know.)  The story of Nathan Drake has a great mix of believable dialogue, humor and thrills.  And while it doesn’t attempt to hit the same emotional highs as Heavy Rain, it also avoids any glaring missteps or massive plot holes.  The structure is also more advanced than your average video game yarn.  Rather than follow a typical linear plot, the game throws you in the middle of the action on the derailed train and fills things in via flashback as you progress.  This is a classic narrative trick used to great effect here. 
 
No Caption Provided
For me, the real strength of Uncharted 2 isn’t about the story itself, but about how seamlessly it works.  The tale spun here by game director and scribe Amy Hennig is nearly perfect in the context of the overall gaming experience.   The action elements blend with the story elements to create a compelling, cohesive experience.  Everything just sort of made sense, and I never felt side-tracked by any of the cinematic interludes.

For comparison’s sake, let’s talk about Batman: Arkham Asylum.  While the tale of Batman’s quest to bring down the Joker was undoubtedly well-written and exciting, there were quite a few times where I hoped for a “skip” button during story interludes.  Frankly, I just wanted to get back to slow motion punching guys in the face (in the parlance of GB’s Ryan Davis) rather than watch Batman walk slowly with a finger to his ear. 

With Uncharted 2, I never felt the itch to skip a cut scene.  Even on my successive playthroughs (now up to 3 times through and counting) I often sit back and enjoy the interplay between Drake and co. unfold, even though I know everything that happens – that’s a testament to a wonderfully crafted piece of fiction.

No Caption Provided
Moving forward, game developers need to realize that it isn’t solely about professional writing or voice actors.  A memorable story also has to work within the context of the overall gaming experience.  In the early days of Hollywood, film writers struggled with similar issues.  It too was a new medium for storytelling that was different from everything that had come before.  Much early film writing was simple or cribbed directly from the theatre.  It took screenwriters some time to gain a real understanding of the machinations of film and how they could be used to tell stories in NEW ways. 

As a medium, video games as an interactive storytelling device are in their infancy.  It will be some time before we come to realize the new and exciting ways we can tell stories interactively.  Video game creators need to learn to strike the right balance between narrative and gameplay, and look at new ways to incorporate the two.  They must realize that they need to be two parts of a single whole, not separate entities entirely.  In my opinion, Uncharted 2 walks this line better than any game I have played in some time, and I wait with bated breath for the next effort from Amy Hennig and Naughty Dog.   
8 Comments

8 Comments

Avatar image for irishdoom
Irishdoom

400

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 10

User Lists: 1

Edited By Irishdoom

No Caption Provided
I realize that in a lot of ways a good story is way down on the list of important gaming elements.  It is a largely visual medium that focuses primarily on interactivity, so it doesn’t necessarily supply the same blank tapestry fit for a compelling narrative like a novel or film.  The fact remains, however, that video games are no longer just “child’s play.”  As the age demographic of gamers skews ever upward, the demand increases for more meaningful experiences.  Strong storytelling is an excellent way to keep older gamers interested, and Uncharted 2 is an excellent example of how the industry is slowly moving from the old ways of game story as an afterthought to fully fleshed-out, engaging narratives. 
In the early days of video games, they were created by small, dedicated teams that had to put a whole package together: graphics, gameplay, sound and story.  These small teams put a premium on flexibility and multiple skill sets – dedicated writers didn’t really have a place.  It made sense in the early days of game development.  After all, how strong a story do you actually need for Super Mario Bros. or Tetris? 

As budgets and development teams have evolved, writers have begun to play a much more pivotal role, and the overall quality of the narrative in games has increased tremendously as a result.  Just take a look at some of the best games of the last six months or so, and you’ll see that good writing playing a pivotal role – Batman: Arkham Asylum, Assassin’s Creed II, Mass Effect 2, the list goes on and on. 

When I first played through Heavy Rain, I thought it would be the ideal example to hold up in order to address the state of storytelling, but I was wrong.  I got too hung up on some of the story’s foibles that were largely related to bad translation – then I played Uncharted 2.  (I’m late to the party, I know.)  The story of Nathan Drake has a great mix of believable dialogue, humor and thrills.  And while it doesn’t attempt to hit the same emotional highs as Heavy Rain, it also avoids any glaring missteps or massive plot holes.  The structure is also more advanced than your average video game yarn.  Rather than follow a typical linear plot, the game throws you in the middle of the action on the derailed train and fills things in via flashback as you progress.  This is a classic narrative trick used to great effect here. 
 
No Caption Provided
For me, the real strength of Uncharted 2 isn’t about the story itself, but about how seamlessly it works.  The tale spun here by game director and scribe Amy Hennig is nearly perfect in the context of the overall gaming experience.   The action elements blend with the story elements to create a compelling, cohesive experience.  Everything just sort of made sense, and I never felt side-tracked by any of the cinematic interludes.

For comparison’s sake, let’s talk about Batman: Arkham Asylum.  While the tale of Batman’s quest to bring down the Joker was undoubtedly well-written and exciting, there were quite a few times where I hoped for a “skip” button during story interludes.  Frankly, I just wanted to get back to slow motion punching guys in the face (in the parlance of GB’s Ryan Davis) rather than watch Batman walk slowly with a finger to his ear. 

With Uncharted 2, I never felt the itch to skip a cut scene.  Even on my successive playthroughs (now up to 3 times through and counting) I often sit back and enjoy the interplay between Drake and co. unfold, even though I know everything that happens – that’s a testament to a wonderfully crafted piece of fiction.

No Caption Provided
Moving forward, game developers need to realize that it isn’t solely about professional writing or voice actors.  A memorable story also has to work within the context of the overall gaming experience.  In the early days of Hollywood, film writers struggled with similar issues.  It too was a new medium for storytelling that was different from everything that had come before.  Much early film writing was simple or cribbed directly from the theatre.  It took screenwriters some time to gain a real understanding of the machinations of film and how they could be used to tell stories in NEW ways. 

As a medium, video games as an interactive storytelling device are in their infancy.  It will be some time before we come to realize the new and exciting ways we can tell stories interactively.  Video game creators need to learn to strike the right balance between narrative and gameplay, and look at new ways to incorporate the two.  They must realize that they need to be two parts of a single whole, not separate entities entirely.  In my opinion, Uncharted 2 walks this line better than any game I have played in some time, and I wait with bated breath for the next effort from Amy Hennig and Naughty Dog.   
Avatar image for zanzibarbreeze
zanzibarbreeze

3251

Forum Posts

3427

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 14

User Lists: 6

Edited By zanzibarbreeze

Uncharted 2 wasn't just the best video game of 2009; it was also the most important video game of 2009, especially in terms of its story among other things. It really shows that video games can have great story and great dialogue as long as the right people are behind it. The fact that almost every line in the game script was perfectly crafted really shows what you can do when you actually put effort into the script to make it sound realistic. The final scene with Drake and Elena (no spoilers) really shows this. The way the voice actors interacted naturally, the way the characters bounced off each other - it was as if it was a conversation in real life. Most television shows and films aren't even that natural. Like, I've been watching old seasons of 24, and it's a great show, one of top three easily, and while the dialogue is acceptable for the kind of show it is, it's also completely unnatural. Nobody talks that ham-handedly in real life. Uncharted 2 is the polar opposite.
 
So, yes, I agree, Uncharted 2 - best game of 2009 (also probably best game of 2010, just cause), best story of 2009, best dialogue of 2009, best acting of 2009, et cetera, ad infinitum.

Avatar image for irishdoom
Irishdoom

400

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 10

User Lists: 1

Edited By Irishdoom

I agree.  One of the issues is some people want to dismiss the story as not much more than a summer blockbuster.  Well, I happen to ENJOY a good summer blockbuster, and perhaps that's the type of tale that can work really well within the context of a video game.

Avatar image for redroach
RedRoach

1402

Forum Posts

249

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By RedRoach

couldn't have said it better myself.

Avatar image for zanzibarbreeze
zanzibarbreeze

3251

Forum Posts

3427

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 14

User Lists: 6

Edited By zanzibarbreeze
@irishdoom said:
" I agree.  One of the issues is some people want to dismiss the story as not much more than a summer blockbuster. "
In any case, I don't think that's a fair dismissal. For me, Uncharted 2's story is the best video game story because of its construction and its execution. The subject matter doesn't have any bearing on that.
 
What's an example of a game with a more "serious" story? Metal Gear Solid 2? Yeah, well, Uncharted 2 is miles better than Metal Gear Solid 2.
Avatar image for evo
EVO

4028

Forum Posts

20

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 4

Edited By EVO

I think what makes Uncharted's story so good isn't necessarily the writing, but the characters. They're just so damn likable.

Avatar image for irishdoom
Irishdoom

400

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 10

User Lists: 1

Edited By Irishdoom

I also didn't mention this, but I never once looked at UC2's story as a video game story.

Avatar image for zanzibarbreeze
zanzibarbreeze

3251

Forum Posts

3427

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 14

User Lists: 6

Edited By zanzibarbreeze

I don't look at video game stories as video game stories. If it's good, then great, if it's bad, then it's bad (as most video game stories are). Take the Metal Gear franchise, for example. Most people claim it has good overall story. I would say that it has a good scenario -- that is, the plot is good. But the dialogue is nothing to write home about, and Kojima gets bogged down in things that I would say he probably doesn't understand, like world affairs and geopolitics. Also, a lot of Metal Gear seems as if it has been written by a child or a young adult -- like what happens to Snake in MGS3, and how he reacts to situations. By contrast, Max Payne 2 has a great story with great scripting and dialogue, even though it borders on silly sometimes, but that's okay, for one reason: it knows what it is, and it's not trying to be something it's not. Uncharted 2 works in the same way. There's no room for stupid live action footage of polar bears in Drake's world, nor is there space for one man's tantrum about how nuclear weapons exist.