Yep, totally stole this idea from the 'Rate The Last Movie You Saw'. That out of the way, how would you rate the last game you finished?
I'll start. I just finished Metsl Gear Solid 2. I'll give it a 3/5. The gameplay is much improved over the original, it still looks great, the VO is really well done (even Raiden), the cutscenes are well shot and there are really cool moments. And the main theme is great (and incredibly under-used).
But, as improved as the controls were I still didn't feel like I had a lot of control over the movement. Raiden has so little momentum when he moves. His movement curve is an immediate ramp up. Subtly was just not there. Then how it all ends. I'll stay away from spoilers. But Jesus Christ. I like MGS 4's brand of nuts. That game was over the top in a bombastic sort of way. MGS 2 is just absurd because of the characterizations, story contrivances, and the juvenile philosophy nonsense. Then it just falls so flat. It felt like there should be a third act but there's nothing. And Raiden feels like the sidekick, filling in a supportive role running parallel to a much more interesting story. When I was done, I didn't feel anything at all. It all just sort of happened. Maybe my expectations were too high.