I'll be honest and say I'm not too keen on any of your choices except Torchlight, so that gets my vote. Unless you've already played through it to completion at least once? If you haven't, by all means I'd say go for that one.
I just had the craziest thought! My brother, my brother, my brother, my brother, and our Dad. 20 years from now Vinny hosts a show with all his children giving advice and answering Google Answers (it's the future) questions.