I don't understand why everyone is so mad over this topic. If the second analog stick makes games better and brings in more games and 3rd party support then its a win-win for everybody. If the analog stick sucks Nintendo will drop support of the second analog stick. And no one says that 1st party and 3rd party games will lose it's innovation because of a second analog stick.
Star Fox or Sonic the Hedgehog because all of there sequels with a few exceptions have been crap. Star Fox 64 and Sonic the Hedgehog 1, 2, 3, and Adventure. Just remake the classics and put Fox back in an Arwing and Sonic on a 2d plane.