GOTY 2011
Games I own that I'm guessing might make this list if I had played much of them yet: Witcher 2, Arkham City, Deus Ex, Superbrothers, Gears 3
Games I don't own that would probably have a shot: Uncharted 3, maybe Saint's Row based on all the crazy hype (I wouldn't come anywhere near it if there weren't so much buzz around it. Soooo not up my alley in any way.)