I have definitely been on board with it, but can see some valid criticisms folks have leveled. Yes, the show rotation has been scattershot lately, though maybe I am just willing to give things a bit more of a pass during the holiday seasons here in the US.
I echo I would love to see more of Tam and Lucy on the regular. I don't begrudge them juggling work on both sites and know they have their plates full, but they are absolutely joys to have involved in videos and audio content.
Speaking of audio content, while nothing will likely ever hit the highs of the Beastcast for me, I think the flagship Bombcast is better than it has been since the east/west split. During those years, the Bombcast still had Gerstmann and Brad to bring the knowledge and historical contexts, but was lacking any spark of joy that made it a great listen. To me, while Gerstmann was the heart of the site Vinny was the soul that sparked everything up to make it better. When Vinny and crew went east that spark was gone on the Bombcast.
Since the revamp, Jan has been great at filling that role of keeping folks involved, engaged and keeping the energy up. I am in my mid 30's so a lot of the more modern references miss me, but the excitement in the delivery makes me not care so much about that. I just think the overall positivity and fun seems back in the Bombcast where folks sound happy to be there and to spend time talking to each other and us by proxy. Even if some more in depth critique may be lacking, I enjoy listening to a discussion that folks are happy to be having.
Covid era showed just how tired the original crew were getting. The grind combined with the issues with CBS through RV took it's toll and sapped a lot of the joy out the process once it was remote and you lose that human connection of in person work. I think the change was good for all involved. I listen to Nextlander's podcast and watch the shows that interest me. Gerstmann's stuff is more sporadic for me. When he is absolutely engaged I love it, but there was a reason we never had 5 Jar Time videos a week on Giant Bomb. It's hard to carry that much solo content week after week.
As for the new crew, I believe they all bring something unique to the site that they can provide. We have seen glimpses of what they can do together and I would love to see that hit rate continue to rise as they just try things and see what works and what doesn't. I look forward to seeing what next year looks like as things continue to gel.
Log in to comment