Jeff's escapade as a drunken Santa from 12/15/09. Why? It has all the elements of a classic story: a drunken Jeff Gerstmann and a Mortal Kombat machine. I'll try to think of more and get dates for you.
Also, Johnny V putting porn on a NBA player's PSP.
Lost my temper with Kenny (after he lost his with me I might add)
Didn't kill the stranger (I guess I just did a poor job with that QTE)
Easily my number 1 game of this year. The moment when Lilly shoots Carley I yanked the power cord out of my computer because I hit the wrong button and thought I caused it. Unfortunately I was wrong. I was far too glad to drop Ben after he told it was his fault the best shot in the group was killed. That fucker.