@donchipotle said:
@karkarov said:
So you like the train wreck that is the story of FF8 why again? It boggles my mind that people think 7 sucked, but the absolute monstrosity of plot that was 8 was good, and the god of generic forgettable 9 was excellent. Suffice to say, yes Adel would have made a better villain, but a one armed monkey from outerspace with the power to shoot lazerbeams out of their eyes would have been a better villain than Ultimecia. So that isn't saying a whole lot.
I think FF8's story has a lot of interesting bits in it that are pushed aside in favor of the sloppy romantic angle they push between Squall and Rinoa. There's a lot of really interesting backstory to the world of 8 and I like that aspect of it. The aspect of time travel and its heavier sci fi leanings, anyway. The problem with 8's plot is that it has an identity crisis halfway through.
There are a lot of reasons most people (out side of hipsters and people jumping the bandwagon) think FF 6 and 7 are the best FF's. Chief among them is the villain. Kefka and Sepiroth are both introduced to the game fairly early, in Kefka's case like in the first hour. You interact and deal with them throughout the whole story. Ultimately you are given a laundry list of reasons to not like them and actual specific examples of why the characters in your party will hate them. Sepiroth burned Clouds hometown to the ground and killed his mother, Kefka killed Terra's father and shoved him in a materia, etc etc. Even better these things are not told in a "two years ago blah blah happened" you either have to play through them as flashbacks or you actually participate in them as real time events you are trying to stop. Kefka even had that annoying laugh and most people wanted to kill Sephiroth for no other reason than being a stupid looking bishie.
Point is, by the end of the game you knew the villains, understood them to a point, had build up a relationship with them, and they (plus the party) have matured or changed based on the events you experience first hand in the game. All this comes down to one thing... you wanted to take them down by the time you got to the end of the game. It was personal, you didn't like them, and they didn't like your characters.
Then you have the other FF's....
Who is the villain of FF10 again? Do they even "have" a name? FF8 you get Ultimicia... no comment even needed as most FF8 players don't even know who she is. FF 9 you got.... some dude whose name I cant recall but he gets replaced by an even more emo Vegeta at the end anyway. I can give more examples, but in my opinion that is one of the big reasons FF 6/7 are normally the favorites of the series on any poll with a large number of votes. Especially if the people grew up with final fantasy instead of grew up with 9 being their first or some such.
Log in to comment