Moonrise Kingdom is also my number one, one of the most endearing films I've ever seen (Once Upon a Time in Anatolia is a close second) . Dredd was better than expected (I expected a Green Lantern level of quality, but got one of the better comic adaption films of the last 5 years) but I still think that a potato could act better than Karl Urban. Skyfall was great, the truest Bond film of the Craig attempts, with spectacular and absurd locations, a good amount of humor and they brought back Q which was dope. I never understood the Avengers love, it's a better than average action film with nothing to distinct itself from the rest of the crowd.
Torchlight 2. I am completely biased as it's my favourite game of the year but I think that most critics didn't have time to play it outside of the review. The cynic in me says it's because it wasn't a title with the name Diablo despite the fact that Torchlight 2 was dubbed by many as what Diablo 3 should have been. But then again I never heard it mentioned when the bombcrew discussed the games they had to play before GOTY.