@zirilius: I agree with everything you've said, I purchased the game but am using GameStop's 7-day GamePlay Guarantee to trade it in for PSN credit and so didn't mind the length. I absolutely loved the story (except the ending) and really hope they get to expand the world they've created. Still want to know a few things though:
Why weren't we allowed to spare Lucan?
Why didn't Gallahad inform Isi of his findings at the time and why did she lose her shit so quickly?
All of the main villains are still alive (Hastings, main chancellor is a douche, all the vampires from the other cargos headed to India and the "New World" made it?, etc)
What was the epilogue about? Less than 10 lines of dialogue lol.
I'd give it a solid 8/10 with the points lost due to the lack of story closure and some broken gameplay mechanics (Almighty shotgun fighters, QTE for stealth kills?, lack of replay ability).