Since you can find most of these games for $15 or less, it's hard to make a real dud of a purchasing decision. My vote went for Lost Odyssey, but I didn't play Tales. Eternal Sonata is worth checking out too; it seemed pretty unique to me, a fairweather JRPG guy.
I'm glad to see Double Fine go downloadable, though it's unfortunate that they're moving to that front out of necessity. I was first hoping for something a little more Castle Crashers-y, but this seems alright too.
I've always liked Brian. If you need convincing that he's a personality worth following, check out his self-produced parody show Voices in the Box. He does all the voices. Wherever he ends up, I hope he's given the option to podcast.