Because two exclamation marks means you're super serial about it! 
I have this weird goal of going through each show and taking copious notes, as this whole college thing has taught me. 
 
This is a fluid list.  Beta as its popular to be known as.  Things are going to be dynamic, pertaining to formatting and such, until I get a feel for how things are going to turn out.  Categories may be added, renamed, or simply taken away on 'cast to 'cast basis. Let me know if you see something wrong!  This is as much mine as it is yours!  
 

Legend:   

• Voices - obvious enough, who's in the podcast
• Reviewed - initially going to be reserved for the taste testing they did early on in the series, will see how things turn out later when they start phasing it out 
• Movies mentioned - despite being a videogame-centric podcast, these guys have some serious debates on movies and people/ideas pertaining to them
• Games mentioned - games/game series mentioned on the 'cast.  Listed if the game has some type of discussion or context behind it, not simply if name dropped
• Names dropped - much like the games mentioned, people mentioned if it pertains to the 'cast
• Out of context quotes - the tiny crazy bits we all love our boys saying.  taken directly out of context makes it even more hilarious
• Timestamps-the parts of the 'cast that are fairly easy to distinguish with Ryans segway ability.  Oft times these will seamless lead into a bigger discussion on the topic
• Definitive quotes - the bits where they're all business, and give their honest opinion/prediction on a topic. If you were to jump to a time in the 'cast, these would be it
• General notes - ideas I've garnered from the crew during the 'cast
• ******* - multiple astricks denote a few minutes of the 'cast you'd do well listening to, if for nothing else than the hilarity/gravitas of it all     
• 1+ - denotes where they talk about a certain topic for more than a minute, instead of simply dropping the name in there for no discussion.

Voices

Games Mentioned

• Dragon Ball Z Burst Limit (4.50)              1+
• Banjo Kazooie Nuts and Bolts (7.55)             1+
• Viva Pinata Trouble in Paradise (7.57)          1+
• Eye of Judgement (9.12)
• Gears of War 2 (16.45)              1+
• Fable 2 (22.01)             1+
• Fable (24.16)
• Too Human (27.38)        1+
• Ninja Gaiden 2 (28.44)          1+
• Penny Arcade Adventures (28.46)
• Haze (32.18)            1+
• Metal Gear Solid 4 (38.44)           1+
• Castlevania DS version (48.53)
• Rock revolution (56.22)
• Singstar (1.02.15)
• Splinter Cell Conviction (1.25.50)

Names Dropped

• Jack Thompson (3.41)
• Cliff Blezinski (16.50)       1+
• Peter Molyneux (22.02)        1+

Out of Context Quotes

• I don't think Jack Thompson likes to party - vinny (3.42)
• its amazing what you can do when you don't have a job - jeff (4.18)
• there is supposedly some love interest for Marcus in the game, and it's not dom - jeff (19.55)
• can you still kiss on dudes? - ryan (27.24)
• episodic games are now about as long as Haze - jeff (32.31)
• so Korn is not in the game - jeff (34.39)
• he aint rumbling wrong, he's rumbling so right - jeff (40.27)
• So she's a man hater huh? - alex (49.13)
• I made a paperclip chain.  It's really long. - vinney (1.57.57)

Timestamps

• World Exclusive Employment Announcement tease (2.29)
• What Have You Been Playing (3.58)
• Pre-E3 events (6.54)
• E-mails (1.30.16-1.50.00)

1. Demo's for WiiWare (1.30.34)
2. Gears of War isn't all that original (1.33.43)
3. Whats with Microsoft backing big JRPGs on a tiny 360 Japanese market (1.35.44)
4. Whatever happened to Dinocrysis (1.37.45)
5. SPOILERRRRRZZZZZZ111!!!!!!1 (1.40.27)                 ***********
6. how to enjoy FF7 (1.44.44)                          **********
7. Name his 5-week old kitten (1.46.53)
8. Killer Kuts cd (1.48.28)

• WORLD EXCLUSIVE GIANT BOMB ANNOUNCEMENT (1.50.03)           ************
• Matresses (1.55.45)                              ************

General Notes

• Ryan is all kinds of out of it, sick and such
• 1st time we hear Vinny on the 'cast (1.32)
• Vinny enjoys some Tahoe Time, as everybody should
• ryan doesn't like metal gear