I liked The Order.
That said, its sins are numerous, even if I could overlook many of them.
Forced slow walking
Audio diaries that have to be played from a menu
Instant failure stealth
Useless objects to inspect that are indistinguishable from important ones
The total amount of gameplay is pretty small
The gameplay itself lacks variety
Again, I enjoyed the game, but it was about five hours, the first one or two being quite bland. The opening set the tone for me to just push through thr game as quickly as possible. It felt like the developers didn't respect my time. It's probably a hard thing to heap high praise upon if it's not doing something special or new.
Short itself isn't bad, but The Order ended suddenly. I was shocked when it ended. The final gameplay section (the shooting, not the QTEs) seemed like another of the late-game's firefights, not the epic conclusion. The game picked-up speed and just ended. It's better than overstaying its welcome, but it's still jarring. I very much enjoyed it, but it has a lot of issues.