So did anyone else solve who was the killer before Crooked Man tells you? The game never gives you a opportunity to say "Gorgie is the killer and here's why..." so if you don't figure it out on your own it can seem really random. I played all the episodes back to back so i feel like I had an easier time piecing evidence together. Even then I only found two
Evidence that Gorgie was the killer
1. Gorgie seems to be the only other character besides Bigby that smokes Huff n Puff cigarettes. In episode 2 when you find a used cigarette at the crime scene Beauty points out that Bigby seems to be the only person that smokes that brand. In episode 4, Nerissa and Woody raise this point as well. At the start of episode 5 you pay attention, when Gorgie pulls out his smokes they are Huff n Puff brand.
2. Faith's money was in Gorgie's safe. At the Puddin and Pie, if you gave Faith your money (58 dollars) in episode one, you find that exact amount of money in the safe, making that seem like the last place Faith was before she was murdered.
Also I had one nagging question that I never felt I got an answer for
Who was it that TJ heard saying "Stop laughing at me" while dumping the body?