@Cretaceous_Bob said:
Most annoying part of the GOTY podcasts:
Patrick: "[Something]-"
Somebody Else: "[Trying to contribute to the discussion]"
Patrick: "[SOMETHING LOUDER UNTIL FINISHED]"
under stress, people's voices change: tensing of speech-production muscles, increased vocal pitch, increased speed of speech, and repetition of words or phrases are all normal dysfluencies. in a stressful situation (as in the podcasts and on Quick Looks), stuttering usually occurs on the first sound of the first word. i've made this observation before, but i suspect that Patrick might have very mild form of stuttering; when he is interrupted while talking, he repeats the first sound of the word he was saying at that point, several times in rapid succession, each at an increasing volume, until he can finish out the thought. the same happens when he, in turn, jumps in and interrupts someone else.
what i'm saying is it could well be an involuntary psychophysical response--and not some intentionally mean-spirited offense. it sounds silly and i doubt it would happen, but it would help if they would raise their hand to speak with Ryan directing vocal traffic.
@HerbieBug said:
it seems to me that a lot of how that final top 10 played out had as much to do with fatigue and wanting to get the podcast over with than it did about righteous choosing of the year's best games. Since the overall GOTY is the most important bit of the end of year awards, perhaps that should be the first thing deliberated on in future, when everybody is still fresh and engaged in the process, as opposed to the last when everyone is tired and the giving of fucks is few and far between.
I also agree with a previous poster that it makes more sense to make the top 10 a top 3 ordered choices, with seven honourable mentions. The ordering of the bottom seven is stupid and meaningless.
yes and yes.
deliberating on the most important overall GOTY on Day One makes so much sense. if they want to keep the suspense throughout the week, they could simply record first, and release on Day Five.
changing from 'Top 10' to 'Top 3' would mean much more bloodshed since each person wouldn't be able to concede to taking the lesser consolation categories. and user consensus seems to be in favour of increased bloodshed. personally, i'd like that, also. sadly, the GOTY podcasts do not feel like they are for the regular user: these GOTY podcasts seem to be for the transparency of the picking process, largely a dutiful (journalistic?) explanation to--and a teeny handshake with--industry professionals, and as such, i don't see them culling the 'Top 10.'
Log in to comment