" RDR was a great game, but it's definitely now GOTY.  Unfortunately it will be whored out by 90% of all major gaming websites as GOTY as they love to ride Rockstar dick.  

" Can't say I agree with any of these but hey, it's your list.  "

RDR should win best sound design.  
GoW 3 should win best graphics.

i agree with some of those and disagree with some 
overall, good list 
 
i'll fill in your list with my choices :   

(*) = same as yours

• Best Sound Design: BFBC2 (*)
• Most Underrated Game: Mafia II
• Most Overrated Game: Singularity
• Best Sports Game : FIFA 11
• Best MP Game: BFBC2 (*)
• Best Indie Game: Super Meat Boy
• Best Graphics: Just Cause 2
• Best Art Style:  RDR (*)
• Most Disappointing:  Medal of Honor
• Best Story: RDR
• Best Character: John Marston (*)
• Game of the Year: RDR    (*)

When I skimmed over this I misread "Best Indie Game" as "Most Indie Game". I think that would make a good category.

RDR was a great game, but it's definitely now GOTY. 
 
Unfortunately it will be whored out by 90% of all major gaming websites as GOTY as they love to ride Rockstar dick. 
 
Mass Effect 2 should more than likely take GOTY.  
 
To be honest so long as Black Ops doesn't win ANYTHING I'll be happy.

" Can't say I agree with any of these but hey, it's your list.  "

Can't say I agree with any of these but hey, it's your list. 

• Best Sound Design: BFBC2
•  
• Most Underrated Game: Alpha Protocol
•  
• Most Overrated Game: CoD: Black Ops
•  
• Best Sports Game : NBA 2K11
•  
• Best MP Game: BFBC2
•  
• Best Indie Game: Limbo
•  
• Best Graphics: Heavy Rain
•  
• Best Art Style:  RDR
•  
• Most Disappointing:  Heavy Rain
•  
• Best Story: Mass Effect 2
•  
• Best Character: John Marston
•  
•  Game of the Year: RDR