Everything Jeff and Vinny said they dislike about Breath of the Wild on the most recent HotSpot. I love games that deliberately slow down the pace of play. I don't like power fantasies that much; having rain prevent me from climbing a cliff or weapons breaking so that I need to avoid combat actually makes me happy.
If something gets in my way, I'll just go do something else: cook, pick fruit, or whatever. I like that same thing about the downtime in Monster Hunter, just wandering around picking up herbs and whatnot is very relaxing. People often talk about video games not respecting the player's time, but those arguments always strike me as an oversimplification. If my goal is to live another life, even the mundane, slower parts, then I'm making a contract with the game to do so. Not everyone plays games for that reason, I know, but I really enjoy the escapism. Living an adventurer's life without any of the risk is a good time.
Breath of the Wild is great because it fulfils those desires in compelling ways, since the number of interactions you can have in the world are almost endless, even if most of them don't have a specific purpose vis a vis killing bad guys or 'winning'. Dwarf Fortress is another game in that vein, where bad guys are just an incidental part of a dangerous world, but you could just choose to focus on making a Dwarven holy city full of religious artworks and temples and hope it doesn't fall to a goblin siege. But if it does, then you'll leave behind some beautiful ruins which add texture to the game world.
I have pretty different tastes than some, especially Jeff. :P Call of Duty is the furthest thing from an interesting gaming experience to me, but the benefit of personality-driven journalism is that I know something about Jeff's tastes and can treat his opinions accordingly. I don't ignore them altogether, but when he has a grievance with a game it is easy to tell if it is something that would bother me, and similarly there are things he loves about games that do not grab me at all. I don't think I'd call any of these games 'underrated', since it really is just a matter of taste; it can be a bit bothersome, though, when people insist that a game is objectively good or bad. Especially if, in the process of doing so, they outright dismiss the game's fans as stupid, wrong or whatever else.
Log in to comment