I picked up a copy of Heavenly Sword last week to participate in the upcoming
Rebel FM Game Club. I had checked out review scores and was expecting the depths of mediocrity. After putting in an hour or so over the weekend, I was pleasantly surprised to find a polished action game with lots of variety. In that short time, I experienced a few very satisfying sword-fighting beat 'em up sequences, shot down incoming enemies with some kind of crazy bow weapon, and used a cannon to take out catapults using the Sixaxis to "steer" the cannonballs after firing (cue eye rolls). It was all way more fun than I ever expected. I am particularly impressed with the story, which is intriguing, and the lip-syncing. Several of the games I have been playing recently (e.g. Fallout 3 and inFAMOUS among others) have had glaring issues with lip-syncing. Even though it isn't a big deal, it really takes you out of the experience to see mouths moving seemingly without any regard for the words that are being spoken.
I have noticed a couple of problems. The controls are a bit clunky. Nariko doesn't really respond to my inputs as I would like her to. The aforementioned aftertouch to control projectiles is a bit inaccurate as you might expect, but it is surprisingly enjoyable when used sparingly. Fear is setting in that the honeymoon could be over soon, but, as of right now, I am thoroughly enjoying the game.
Update: Marigold? How silly of me to mistake the main character's name. It is fixed now.