RedBullRacer

Before I brought this I planned to play it multiple times all this weekend, but, after finishing it on Saturday Night...I almost don't want to play it again and I haven't yet. I think it will be fun to play it knowing who the killer is, but at the same time, I don't want to spoil the story ...I got a really sad ending, but it was my ending, I almost feel like I would be cheating the story if I played it again. 
 
I may leave it, but I can't stop thinking about this game. I love the characters so much, and the way it made me feel while playing it, I sure hope they release loads of dlc for this game!

 I was lying in bed this morning thinking about the ending to this game and I think the problem for me is not with the actual typewriter scene, it's the way they show you him hitting that bloke over the head with the typewriter. They only showed a 3sec clip of him smacking him on the head in the reveal. This left me confused until I read on the forums after that he does this while Lauren is looking at the ballerina box.

If in the reveal, they had made it a longer scene, showing Lauren looking at the Ballerina box with the camera at a different  angle showing Shelby sneaking off round the back, then hitting him over the head with the typewriter, then back to Lauren looking at the box before showing Shelby walking back in with that smile on his face, which now has a different meaning! I think I would have loved that, cos it would have made sense...instead I ended up playing the rest of the game thinking my game had bugged on me cos I couldn't work out how he hit him on the head!    

It's a classic to me cos, some of the scenes just had me literally crying oh no with fear as I missed buttons cos I felt like I was gonna get killed. Also, I actually panicked on one occasion because of the situation and it resulted in someone dying, bloody brilliant...like you say, I panicked cos of what was happening on screen and so I ended up acting like the character! amazing, also, when your following that red balloon at the start and all them people are there, it's like a real crowded room and so frustrating not being able to reach the balloon...again, you felt like what the character would actually be feeling!

Jayden (ALIVE): quit the FBi and walked out of the office never to be seen again
Ethan (DEAD): shot by the cops, thought to be the killer 
Shelby (ALIVE): alive and walking the streets 
 Lauren (DEAD): died in the car under the water     
Madison (ALIVE): curled up on the sofa in fear of the men wearing masks who don't exist

This one scene with the ballerina box, almost ruins the game for me...cos it is a bit of a cheap trick and this game is so much better then that for the rest of the game. They could have done it so many other ways, they could have had that person ring back and you control the hooker and answer the phone so are on the phone or anything, but its a bit of a cheap trick. Other then that one scene, this game is bloody amazing!

Has to be Jack, just cos the way you pick her up is soooooo cool! When she popped up out of that prison thingy, I was like, no way it's a girl! lol I loved that mission, I also really like Miranda, just cos she's got a nice ass :) 

This is my Shepard, Kevin Shepard! 

I lost Jacob, I was gonna send Tali down the tubes but there was no way I was gonna risk her getting killed...so seeing as Jacob wanted to do it, I let him do it! I would have cried if Tali died...