Everyone who has a Kinect that has tried for any length of time to use it as a voice remote knows two things. You can't carry a conversation when navigating menus and you can't use it when you want to be quiet for the rest of your house.
If it worked exactly as desired (read: instantly) A remote is always the best choice, there is a reason it's been around for as long as it has. You only need one hand to use it, you can use it in the dark, you can keep your eyes on the TV, it's quiet, the battery life is good, I could go on. The simplest solution is always the best.
None of the other options even come close.
That's the problem with Kinect, even if it works perfectly, you will always need a backup
Log in to comment