Since Tales From the Borderlands isn't completely out yet I'll put my vote towards The Wolf Among Us. I wouldn't call it the best game they've made but it is a solid detective story within the world of Fables.
I could see it being Vinny's Game Of The Year but GOTY overall no. Games released in the fall seem to have a higher chance of getting into the top spot since it will be in their thoughts more than a game that was released 6-12 months ago.
Well thanks to my internet provider I usually have to stick to sub-HD. Otherwise I would be streaming HD all the time like I used to. Although I don't really care if it's SD or HD. No matter the quality I'll still enjoy the content of whatever I happen to be watching.
Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow, the addition of the soul system gave me new ways to deal with the different monsters in the castle. Plus the surprise twist in the story also made this game into my favorite metroidvania.