@snail: I think Jeff reviewing it is a "mistake", not because his opinion is "wrong", but because he obviously doesn't enjoy any of the MMO trappings that are the core of the experience. Same as it would be a "mistake" if I reviewed a sports game because I have no interest in them and would probably find the experience terrible. There's a reason people review games in genres they actually like.
It will be a review worth reading, and a valid opinion. I don't see what your complaint is.
They're too big, and the 5S was better looking than either of them.
Still, taking into consideration the somewhat significantly upgraded innards of the 6, I would probably go with that one given the option of getting any of the 6's and 5's for free. Shame that it's heavier though.