The more i think about it the more "done" Bioshock is. That game's good ending really wrapped it up nice and pretty for me. What i was hoping when there was talk of sequels was something like Shock 2, which really just took the few elements of Shock 1 that were integral to that experience and transposed it to a new setting, adding enough new to it to make it seem fresh again. A simple return to rapture feels like a copout to me.

What really IS Bioshock when the Ryan thread is finished? That game was intensely personal. Take that away and i'm not sure what we're left with. I just know it's not as appealing to me.

Fingers crossed