i genuinely do not scared at most things, but on the rare occasion that i am, it's over the most strange & perculiar thing that i can't for the life of me explain. usually it's not involved in horror.
one thing, that i'll share:
there's a scene in a simpsons episode called 'krusty gets busted', where you see krusty without his makeup on looking coldly at the camera at the back of a police van. and the face absolutely traumatizes me. i want to look up a picture to showcase, but i'm just too afraid to look at it, it still terrifies me.
heavy rain (because it wouldn't fucking work! it freezes everytime i open up crime scene, and takes 10 minutes to load up. i re-installed everything dozens of times and still the same result, i even replayed the entire game up to that part. and the same copy worked fine on my friends console. extremely unhappy with that outcome.)