I just had an electric fist bruiser get the red hit prompt after I jumped over him to hit another regular guy, do a snap 90 degree turn 5 meters away from me , and punch not even in my direction but somewhere off to the right and hit/shock me in like a split second while skipping through animations.
And i lost count of how many times I've seen the cape stun go through a secondary target and do nothing instead of stunning and interrupting their attack. Other times it will barely touch them and still stun so you counter and whiff. Getting hit and dropping combos in a Batman combat system through no fault of your own? Fuck that. It's only a good system, as long as it's following it's own rules to a T, that polish in the first 2 games is a huge part of what makes it all work. This is why City is still the best that style of combat has ever been.
Still I am liking the story much more then City I have to admit. And with the motion blur properly turned off in the PC version now it's looking a lot better too.