@counterclockwork87: Allowed to and should are not the same thing, and when something happening is wrong it should be written about and talked about. The reasoning behind these 1-star reviews are wrong to people, so it is a story.
@dr_beaverah: I think the podcast does not hit the Premium stream unless they specifically have ads on the podcast that they have removed in order to be a "premium" podcast. I could be wrong, someone on staff might clarify.
There are ads on the 10/21 Bombacast. Still no sign of the Premium version in the feeds. Bummer.
As someone that only owns the PS4, and not an Xbox One I think you should go for the one that you are more likely to play with your friends. Sounds like Xbox One to me. Most of my friends don't have either system, so the content was a bigger factor in my decision.
As to your second question, this game feels great playing with random people so far. YMMV.