I really don't like to criticize things in general. And I love playing games so much that even when games come out that have very little put into them, there is a decent chance that I will play them for many, many hours and not complain very much (Ride to Hell: Retribution, I am looking at you).
There are things that bother me, though. And one of the big ones is game hype. Being someone who plays a very large amount of games (probably only slightly less than people who play games for a living), I really feel as though there are some games that get good reviews in games media when they don't deserve it. Some kind of weird hype builds up, and it frequently starts with pre-release trailers and ends with attempts to turn games into something more than they should be.
So, that rambling preamble leads me to answering the OP with these: The Walking Dead, Bastion, The Last of Us and pretty much any GTA game. Watch Dogs is also one that fits squarely in here. I fear very much now for No Man's Sky, as well.