I finished the game on Sunday, after already hearing quite a bit of the discontent about the ending on podcasts, etc. I was prepared, then, to be a little disappointed, even though I wasn't sure what to expect. So I made my decision, watched the ending, and then thought, "Well, that wasn't great, but it wasn't horrible, either."
Then I went back and replayed the last portion and made a couple different decisions, including the last one. I saw that the second ending I received wasn't that different (read: nearly identical) than the first one. I watched the third choice on YouTube.
You see, on my playthrough, I made some excruciating decisions that led to the deaths of Mordin and Tali, but I lived with those decisions. I thought, "Maybe on a different playthrough, I'd be able to save them." But after seeing how BioWare decided to wrap up each of the endings, I realized that it really didn't matter what decisions I'd made throughout the process. Cure the genophage or not? Didn't really matter. Let the Rachni Queen survive or not? Didn't really matter. Geth or Quarian (I didn't get the choice to save both)? Didn't really matter.
BioWare has every right to see their creative vision to the end, but after spending $200 on their games, I have every right as a consumer to criticize the delivery on their promise of making player choice matter in whatever end they create. I enjoyed the experience of all three games--I really did--and I'm not begging for a refund, either. But I'll tell you what--I'm not going to pony up another $20, $30, or $40 for additional DLC which may or may not alter the ending experience. That's a shameful money grab, promoting something to "add to the legend of Shepard".
My Shepard is dead. That's the ending that BioWare wanted to give me, and I accept it without spending another penny.
Log in to comment