I'm sorry, but I can't get over the fact that you want "Mature Smart Anime" and yet put Code Geass in your likes, and Steins Gate in your dislikes. And the fact that you didn't even bother to finish Baccano.
Code Geass is a great anime to get drunk off your ass and laugh at the ridiculous of it, but it's anything but mature and smart.
Oh man, Brad's arguments were just awful. But whatever. It's dumb but at least it only got 10th I guess. Over much more deserving titles but whatever. Brad.
Nah, there weren't any more deserving titles. Nothing played better than Destiny this year. Wolfenstein was surprising, but if this year wasn't so disappointing overall, you wouldn't see it in any top 10 list. It's not that great. I felt like Destiny would've been bumped in there regardless, because there weren't any serious other games to consider. I was mostly with Jeff: Destiny is probably even better than half of the games that made the list before they even started discussing if Destiny should be put on it.
I'm sorry but when you say "Nothing played better than Destiny this year." your bias very clearly shows itself. You can't just say "The shooting feels so good" as if that encompasses all that is important to a game. You very clearly like Destiny a lot, perhaps even more than Brad, but that doesn't make the multitude of people who thought it was disappointing and didn't belong on the list at all wrong in their judgement.