I finished my 2nd playthrough this evening on 1999 mode and get all of the collectibles I missed. I used the guide located here. It's got a checklist so I loaded it up on my phone and checked each voxaphone off as I found them. That made it really easy to make sure I got everything. If you're doing it because you want to wring out each and every bit of the story you might as well just get all voxaphones again because after knowing the ending and everything that happens some of them take on new meaning. My 1999 run ended up taking less time than my normal run even though I got each and every collectible and died more.
Of all the things that this game does so well, thats kind of a bummer. But already started a 1999 playthrough. Will load up the last save from my previous playthrough and check up on the logs I already have. Bummer about the Kinetoscopes though, those are the worst to find by far.
Hey guys, I just got done with the game and am currently planning another playthrough on hard +1999 Mode and I want to finish collecting all the audio logs (and the video stuff as well). Do the ones I've already done still appear or does it make my life a bit easier and remove the ones I've already got from the game? Thanks!