12 Comments
Posted by ZZoMBiE13

One man's trash is another man's treasure I suppose. I found this kinda funny, you might too.

Who what now???

Edited by Roflwaffles

No surprise here. The Comic Vine staff wouldn't even know a bad comic book if it punched them in the face and insulted their mothers.

Posted by CaptainCody

@Roflwaffles said:

No surprise here. The Comic Vine staff wouldn't even know a bad comic book if it punched them in the face and insulted their mothers.

Damn straight, I remember making a thread over my distaste when they gave BATWOMAN 5 stars repeatedly when the whole comic has been shit. I will continue to approve of most of what Tony does but that's about it.

Posted by JackSukeru

I saw that, mostly because I was gonna read the screened review and pressed the wrong button.

Posted by habster3

... Let's just say I'd take Screened's word over Comic Vine's any day.

Posted by Claude

A lot of people liked it in the comments for the Screened review. I guess it's up to the individual to go see it and form their own opinion.

Posted by Pezen

I don't want to "dig deeper into John Carter."

But hey, look at it like this; if you want to see it for it's comic-connections it's better than if you want to watch it for it's cinematic quality.

Posted by NegativeCero

Reviews are opinions.

Posted by Hizang

I suppose the screened guys rate it on how good the movie is and the Comic Vine guys rate it on how good of an adaptation it is.

Posted by ZZoMBiE13

For the record, I'm not speaking to the quality of either review. I just thought it was funny as I was tabbing through my Whiskey Media sites seeing the double review with such radically different scores coming from essentially the same office.

Posted by Tireyo

A backstreet boy/gladiator movie? Disney messed up big time with this.

Posted by Mageman

Are the comic vine guys even in the same office as the rest of the whiskey group ?