meatsounds's Puzzle Agent 2 (PC) review

A great experience, and oh yes, there are puzzles

To put it briefly, Puzzle Agent 2 is a collection of puzzles which are wrapped in a striking, memorable package: the hand-drawn sprites that make up the graphics are uniformly gorgeous in their sketchy, sparse style; the writing is an effective mix of understated creepiness and dry humour with little injections of the purely bizarre played for great effect; and the voice-acting of the characters is fantastic. There are more puzzles than in the first game, and they are more challenging, which is for the best. While I recommend it to everybody, it's not quite perfect: it is still very short, the joining of the gameplay to the story is still a little forced, and the puzzles, which after all are supposed to be the point of the game, are probably the weakest part of the package. While I appreciate how entertaining the wild swings in the story line are, it is by now obvious that there's no deeper narrative at work here, just a series of cute one-offs as they strike the writers' fancy. Nonetheless, Telltale obviously know what the strengths of Puzzle Agent are - the visuals and the writing - and makes use of them very effectively.

After Special Agent Nelson Tethers did what was asked from him in the first game, re-opening the eraser factory in Scoggins, Minnesota, the case was officially closed. Tethers finds this an unpalatable state of affairs, given the enormous amount of loose ends remaining, and returns to Scoggins on his own initiative to find out what really happened to the factory's foreman, Isaac Davner. Last Tethers saw him, Davner was being dragged off by the Hidden People, the red forest gnomes that haunt the snow-laden woods of Scoggins, its folklore, and the paranoid fantasies of its residents. In the first game, the atmosphere was moody and understated, making its impact by very carefully doling out only hints and suggestions, with the occasional moment of quirky comic relief. In this game, however, Telltale have chosen to let loose with the crazy, keeping you off-guard with a series of bizarre events and visuals. In the first game, every time you see one of the gnomes it's genuinely unnerving, as each sighting carries great significance and they are few and far between. In comparison, if you see the gnomes rarely this time it's because they are sharing the stage with a large array of crazy. For intstance, within 10 minurs or so of the start, Tethers is woken up by an astronaut walking into his hotel room at night with a mysterious green light streaming behind him, and a word puzzle flying out of his helmet. The effect is less Twin Peaks, more Treehouse of Horror. This might be prudent - after all, there's only so long you can draw out a mystery - but by the end of this instalment there still is a large amount of loose ends, and the game pointedly doesn't care. The story isn't the focus, obviously, but instead the setting is. A number of familiar characters return, though none of them have such a show-stealing role as Sheriff Bahg did the first time round, the focus now being more on how Tethers himself is becoming more drawn into the lunatic puzzle gnome world. I would have liked it if there was more of a coherent story arc, and, to put it bluntly, I don't see this train getting back on any tracks in the future. But if you're going to turn your story into a series of zany adventures, you're not likely to do it any better than Puzzle Agent 2 does. The astronaut fascination goes to bizarre and amusing lengths, and the new character of Korka Tetirdottir is fantastic, especially the visuals for her and her house.

The puzzles are, well, more of the same, but a little harder. There's more variation, including an interactive sequence which is halfway between a puzzle and a quick-time event (also, the only time-sensitive part of the entire game). The puzzles aren't quite as forced and disconnected from the story as in the first game, but not by much. Really, I recommend you don't pay all too much attention to them: the puzzles aren't where the action is, the presentation is. This is, as in the first instalment, is a wonderful little experience with a game attached. Everybody would do well to give it a look - it'll stick with you long after you've forgotten all about the puzzles.

6 Comments
Posted by HaltIamReptar

Have you ever played any of the Layton games? I find the puzzles in this series to be more connected to the story than in that series.

Posted by Rolyatkcinmai

Great review. I agree completely. It was a wonderful experience.

Posted by meatsounds

@HaltIamReptar: It's a problem in the Layton games as well - I find the link between the game and the presentation to be pretty contrived for the most part. That Blue Toad Murder Files game did a better job of matching the two, but neither the puzzles nor the setting is all that interesting, really.

Posted by eccentrix

One of my favorite things about the Puzzle Agent game is the contrived link between the puzzles and the setting. It's funny, if anything.

Posted by meatsounds

@eccentrix: They have to try and play the contrived link that way, I think, but I don't find it convincing or compelling. YMMV, of course.

Posted by eccentrix

@meatsounds: It's like how Agent Tethers sometimes stares at things for a long time before reacting. If you assume all the little things like that are intentionally comical, it's a pretty funny game. Or funnier, since it's still funny without all of that.

Other reviews for Puzzle Agent 2 (PC)

    Agent Tethers, You've Done It Again. 0

    Mirror post of my on-site review.Puzzle Agent 2, Telltale Games' sequel to its well-received Puzzle Agent, released last year, is an extended and entertaining continuation of the first game's story and gameplay. While it doesn't do a ton of new and exciting things with the formula, it continues where the first left off with a wildly entertaining storyline, some great mind-boggling puzzles, and an overarching mystery that will keep you going "Huh...What?!" until the end. It also improves on a han...

    0 out of 0 found this review helpful.

    Nice Sequel 0

    Puzzle Agent 2 continues the story of Nelson Tethers: Puzzle Agent almost directly where that one left off. This is a good, because the first game raised more questions than it gave answers.Agent Tethers returns to Scoggins for more puzzles, sadly those are easier puzzles than in the first game. Except for maybe 2 or 3 most puzzles are solvable in a very few steps. This game is no "Layton", but it will require a lot of concentration.Having played game one only 2 days earlier for the first time, ...

    0 out of 0 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.