Has anybody tried to shoot somebodys hat off without killing them yet? :D I think I'll try that later

How big is the map compared to some other games?

Are the horses hard to control? Also do you fall off the horses at any time by the horse tripping on terrain and whatnot?

Hats will fly off if you hit them just the right way leaving the wearer unharmed (not terribly hard).  
 
I changed my horse controls to camera relative, much easier IMO, just don't spam the spur button and you won't fly off.

" How big is the map compared to some other games? "

" Are the horses hard to control? Also do you fall off the horses at any time by the horse tripping on terrain and whatnot? "

Tell me everything about lynching / hanging.

" Lynchings happens as random events and in some quests, here and there, I've seen it twice and you basically go into deadeye(bullettime) and shoot off the rope. "

" 1) What are the graphics like?  2) Do the guns feel good?  3) Explain horseriding  4) Can you Lasso eachother?  5) Can you set a multiplayer nickname? "

I played Red Dead Redemption. Ask me anything.  :P

" @JJWeatherman: Who is your daddy, and what does he do? "

" @JJWeatherman: Who is your daddy, and what does he do? "

" @JJWeatherman: Who is your daddy, and what does he do? "

" @JackG100 said:

" @JJWeatherman: Who is your daddy, and what does he do? "

Master blaster?  "

" I want to know one thing. Are there removable limbs? Amputation. "

is there lock on targeting?  that's the one thing i hated about GTA IV.

" @The_Laughing_Man said:

" @RiotBananas said:

" 1) What are the graphics like?  2) Do the guns feel good?  3) Explain horseriding  4) Can you Lasso eachother?  5) Can you set a multiplayer nickname? "

1. Amazing *Ive heard it called the best looking open world game to date*  

That crown is taken by Just Cause 2. "

" is there lock on targeting?  that's the one thing i hated about GTA IV. "

Is the world bigger than just cause 2's?

"

Is the world bigger than just cause 2's?

"

Trust me you already know him. Aaaall too well.  I don't know what I mean by that. But has anyone here been able to download the soundtrack or the bonus DLC that comes with the special edition? "

Got the game at a midnight launch 
the shooting is SO satisfying, it doesn't even make sense! 
 
there is no limbs amputations, but their heads kinda blow up (in the back) when you headshot them.

" Has anybody tried to shoot somebodys hat off without killing them yet? :D I think I'll try that later "

Me along with three guys where here when I got mine delivered.  *Via Ustream* 
 
PS3 version IS in 720p. The game takes very little time to install. 

Anyone get to try the pre-order bonus items? If so how are they? Kinda feel like your cheating?
 
I opted out of the war horse for The Good The Bad and The Ugly on Bluray. Have yet to pop it in my PS3.

Does the game have horses? 

Do experience gained in MP count for your SP character? or isn't there even leveling on SP?

Are multiplayer posses temporary and just for the duration of a certain round, or can you have up to 7 friends as your steady posse aside from temporary posses you can have during certain rounds ? 
 
in other words, EXPLAIN THE WHOLE POSSE BUSINESS IN DETAIL

What is there to exactly do in mulitiplayer free roam? 
How many guns are in the game?  Possibly name some?

" Do experience gained in MP count for your SP character? or isn't there even leveling on SP? "

" Do you get a house? homestead? Hotel room? camp site? somewhere to live?  Can you own businesses? "

" @RiotBananas said:

" @The_Laughing_Man said:

" @RiotBananas said:

" 1) What are the graphics like?  2) Do the guns feel good?  3) Explain horseriding  4) Can you Lasso eachother?  5) Can you set a multiplayer nickname? "

1. Amazing *Ive heard it called the best looking open world game to date*  

That crown is taken by Just Cause 2. "

Agreed "

@EvolutionX0

" What is there to exactly do in mulitiplayer free roam? How many guns are in the game?  Possibly name some? "

To auto aim or not to auto aim? That is the real question. Anyone tried both difficulties yet?

"  How many guns are in the game?  Possibly name some? "

how are the shops?

" To auto aim or not to auto aim? That is the real question. Anyone tried both difficulties yet? "

"Does the game have horses?  "

" @Zimbo said:

" To auto aim or not to auto aim? That is the real question. Anyone tried both difficulties yet? "

Maybe it's just me, but it didn't feel like there was any auto aim for the few hours I played last night/this morning. "

" @Jeust said:

"Does the game have horses?  "

I heard guys with coconuts do the horses "

" @Zimbo said:

" To auto aim or not to auto aim? That is the real question. Anyone tried both difficulties yet? "

Maybe it's just me, but it didn't feel like there was any auto aim for the few hours I played last night/this morning. "

" @Jeust said:

"Does the game have horses?  "

I heard guys with coconuts do the horses "

" @bybeach said:

" @Jeust said:

"Does the game have horses?  "

I heard guys with coconuts do the horses "

Was there any migrating swallows involved ? "